As my previous suggestion threads got a little off topic and the content was all over the place, I have written my proposals down again in a hopefully clearer format. I might add onto it if i have more proposals and more time to test Krita. But for now there are the 3 main “hurdles” I have faced. T…

The pdf is more clearly worded. Thanks. Would it be possible for you to copy paste the contents to the forum post directly? In case in future the link becomes dead, the post will still have your suggestions.

(I’ll start from a bit of nitpicking tbh, the more significant stuff is in the last part). The “In-herit Alpha” toggle by itself doesn’t do anything It does, but if the layer below is fully opaque, then inheriting alpha from below will just mean that all pixels are the “allowed” ones. If you do …

I guess the proposal/counter-argument like ratio settles this. It was worth a try. There’s nothing more I can do about it. It basically boils down to “Its just not for me”. I probably was a bit over-enthusiastic after seeing how keen the developers were about fixing the bugs I’ve reported. Cheers f…

I think what you really should do for the proposal is to keep it more open. So that people who use photoshop can be used to it like you while also not breaking the current workflow. Cause many like me for example don’t want a dedicated eraser tool, I would prefer less crowded toolbar when possible. …

I don’t agree that the transparency mask of PS is better. It only supports one. In a discussion with my friend a few weeks ago, he said that the mask management of PS is much worse than that of AE. So the direction of improvement should be progress towards AE.

I don’t know if it would make you feel better, but such controversies and difficult discussions and disagreements happen even on purely Krita-based proposals too, for example Krita 5 with putting the visibility changes onto the undo stack isn’t even released but there are already people complaining …

[image] tiar: Krita 5 with putting the visibility changes onto the undo stack isn’t even released but there are already people complaining that it breaks previously-possible workflow and making a wishlist item to make it optional: 446889 – [Request] Make layer visibility being included in the un…

Reading the pdf, i thought the other thread about the eraser made clear that having a dedicated tool for eraser is not useful as it would be a complete copy of the brush tool making it redundant. To me if we are making more tools maybe a secondary brush mode would be a much better option as you coul…

[image] LunarKreatures: i remember being against it when it was proposed i really hope this will be rolled back cause its really annoying. :sweat_smile: I hope it will be kept, on my side I can’t count the number of times I did some undo without seeing that I was doing undo on hidden layers …

[image] LunarKreatures: i dont think krita goal is to be the the one tool all artists uses i know many artists that went to csp instead cause they felt better using it and thats totally fine. The main thing that kept me from using CSP was that the brush engine isn’t as powerful as the one in …

Hurdles of a "Photoshop Guy"

Develop Artists Feedback & Testing

SchrodingerCat December 12, 2021, 11:44pm 11

I join this request, having the layer visibility undone with ctrl + z does disrupt my workflow