Issue with Mac native colour picker (SOLVED)

I sometimes need to pick very specific colour values. Most of the time this happens when working in CMYK directly.

As long as I use Kita’s colour dialogues (eg. the specific colour docker) everything is fine, but if I try to set up a fill layer things start to get messy.
Since I am using Krita on MacOS, I am forced to use the native Mac colour dialogue to choose a fill layer’s colour (at least as far as I could find out), but that one keeps messing up my colour values.

For example, let’s say I need these colour values:

Everything looks fine until I go back and edit that colour. As you can see the colour values are all messed up:

Sampling the colour with Krita’s Colour Sampler Tool will confirm that the CMYK values are not the ones I have originally input into the fileds:
image
Weirdly enough, they also don’t match the values in the the MacOS colour dialogue.

I did make sure that the selected profile is the same for the document and the colour dialogue.
I my example, the document uses ECI Coated v2 and so does the colour picker.

As a side note, I know this a discussion that has been going on and Mac users never seem to be happy with any choice you make, but I really don’t like the native Mac colour dialogue. I’d much rather use Krita’s. It would be really wonderful if I could just choose which one to use in the preferences.

BTW. the profile support on the MacOS colour picker seems buggy in my opinion. I have to click several time on the profile I want to use to actually select it and it keeps changing all the colours.

Anyway, this is a separate topic. Right now, my issue is that anything that will rely on the MacOS colour picker will give me messed up color values.

Hi

Grum999

Hello and welcome to the forum :slight_smile:

In the New File, Content tab, does the Background Colour for a Background as Raster Layer also use the Mac native colour picker?
If it does then my idea for a workaround won’t work.
(Use the Background layer from a newly created file.)

There may be another way of fiddling that but I can’t think of one.

Thanks! For some reason this hadn’t shown up when seatching the forum (or maybe I’m just a bit tired today).
So it looks like this is planned already, I’ll just wait for this to arrive in a future release!

Thanks! Been lurking here for some time as a non registered user. But since Krita has now basically replaced Photoshop for me, for basically everything, I decided to join.

Yes

My workaround for now is to not use fill layers or anything that relies on the MacOS dialog. Instead I use a regular paint layer and use the fill gradient tool to fill in with what I need.

If you want to test it, it should normally be already available in krita next build.

Grum999

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 3 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.