I love statistics 
I’m unfortunately the 1% who never use the freehand selection tool 
On my side, if it’s possible to let the tool remind automatically which mode has been used last time, it would be an interesting compromise for everyone 
Grum999
I’m very sorry for representing the majority and wanting for Krita to gain more popularity from the artists, buddy.
1 Like
What I see here is, @Deif_Lou choose the same order for selection mode in list than in Krita’s default user interface: having a consistency in interface is a good thing.
As you can see, the polygonal selection tool I use in 99% of time (statistics about my usage) is in 3rd place.
I could ask to get it in first place but it will be a non-sense.
Not because 99% of world-wide users don’t use it, but because of consistency with default order in interface.
My proposal to keep in mind the last used method is a good compromise I think.
I remember @halla implemented something about tools settings, but can’t found it… I have to dig in forum.
But if it can be used here to let users being able to keep last tool settings (across session) I think it would fit your need as it would fit my need 
note @Deif_Lou: I didn’t had the time to watch the 17minutes video yet, maybe this is already implemented, maybe not. Accept my apologies if it’s already implemented 
Grum999
The point of this is to fill by creating quick and dirty regions around. Doesn’t using a bezier path make it more cumbersome?
By the way, I don’t think this tool will be the most useful in every case. I also implemented the “continuous fill” in the fill tool (click and drag to fill more than one region in one pointer press/move/release iteration), and I think that can be as useful.
I’ve put the lasso as the default, but the settings are stored when you change them. So they are loaded the next time as you left them. The solution to this is to have tool presets as @Grum999 says. That way you can have multiple sets of settings stored and you can easily switch between them.
It should be. It is made just like the other tools.
1 Like
I’ve just implemented new region selection modes that instead of filling the closed areas, allow to fill around some specific color, but leaving the closed areas untouched, kind of the opposite. But it’s experimental. Here is a video showing it. Sorry the menus don’t show up, but I think it’s clear. Also, the erase mode in krita can be used with the tool to remove the areas around:
14 Likes
I don’t think so. Bezier curves will use polylines as long as they are not dragged. But polygon can’t use curves.
There are times when facing a slightly complex object, a polyline requires several clicks, while a curve would be much easier
1 Like
This is sorcery.
1 Like
OMG this is magic.
I would not even have problem even if i paint the way i do now, if i can magic wand erase it this way. Woahhh. Im blown. You sir is amazing.
1 Like
Ok, after some time… I finished it: Add "Enclose and Fill" tool (!1415) · Merge requests · Graphics / Krita · GitLab
Still, I need to tackle some things and there has to be some review. I leave a video here showcasing the tool (keep in mind that I only use this tool there, and that some simple regions would be filled faster with the fill tool, just one click) :
12 Likes
Now I still think “Path Selection Tool” is a better choice than “Polygonal Selection Tool”. It can draw straight lines and curves, and more importantly, it can be withdrawn by right-clicking, which “Polygonal Selection Tool” cannot do.
PS: Once I asked someone how to withdraw the “Polygonal Selection Tool”, he said: Why don’t you use the “Path Selection Tool” it? I tried it and found it worked well. Now I even doubt if we can remove “Polygonal Selection Tool” because there is nothing special about it.
From previous talk this does not seem to be a code problem. So I’d like to see what other community members have to say.
Excellent, this will really help a lot the work process of several of us
Speaking of Clip, it is interesting how it manages the tools, even users can create their own version.
I can’t wait to try it.
This is fantastic !!!
It can become such a helpful tool for comics flatting and colouring !
I will be eagerly waiting for this 
!!
@TheTwo, I agree with you, but I forgot to change that. I just have done the changes and now it uses the path tool instead of the polygon.
1 Like
Sorry this will be a bit off- topic for this thread but i kinda want to explain a possible misunderstanding.
The way clip studio names things is a bit misleading. From my understanding what clip allows is for you to create presets for tools, not new tools, you can configure a new preset using the already available settings. No different from making brushes.
I believe the krita devs are working on something similar, tool presets. At least i remember halla showing something like that a while ago.
Just wanted to clear this up.
1 Like
Yes, that’s what I meant by it’s “own version”, maybe the problem is the translation, English is not my main language, but I did mean that, new presets.
1 Like
It looks great, but I encountered some problems during compilation. After consulting relevant materials, I found that krita’s current QT version is 5.12.12, but clear is a function added in QT version 5.13. Is there any way to solve this problem? Thank you!
@urzeye I normally use my system’s qt to compile, which is 5.15, so this happens sometimes (who would thought a function like clear was added so late to QPainterPath). Anyway, I already pushed a fix.
Keep in mind there is still an issue I talk about at the end of the MR description.
Thanks for testing.
1 Like
Damn! looks amazing each time I see your demo videos
1 Like